Category Archives: reatuarant reviews Marietta

West Cobb Diner

West Cobb Diner

Elma and I give it 3 1/2 stars with potentila for 5

Located behind Waffle House at the corner of Barrett Pkwy and Dallas Hwy (770)422-7717

When we first saw the sign for “Grand Opening/ West Cobb Diner”  I really was not expecting anything great.  I mean…diner food is…well…diner food.  I was thinking greasy burgers, and Cobb salads.

I was pleasantly surprised.

The head chef previously owned a restaurant in South Carolina and for the past several years has been cooking and catering for Atlanta’s “elite” (so I’m told). The establishment is a family affair with brother-in-law bankrolling, and wife and other family members helping out in front.  I will say one thing:  this guy can cook.

Our rating system consists of a five-star rating on six categories.

Quality:  The food quality was definitely good. There were ingredients that could have been used pre-prepared, but they chose fresh every time.  I had the Mimi’s Italian Chopped Salad, with chick peas, artichokes, hearts of palm, roasted red peppers, white beans, sun-dried tomatoes, and lightly battered and freshly fried eggplant cubes. ($7.00)  Every ingredient was crispy and delicious and the eggplant pieces are done to order so they were delightfully light and crispy.

Mimi's Italian Chopped Salad

When you see things on this “diner” menu like creme fraiche and remoulade you know that the level of cooking far exceeds that of a short order cook.

Elma had the Crab Sliders which very nice and full of crab meat, not bread crumbs.

I had the chocolate cake for dessert which tasted a bit like a “bake sale” cake with vanilla icing.  (I notice that this is not on the printed menu. It must be on trial—keep trying)  Next time I will try the Sweet Potato Pecan Pie, which I believe is made in-house as is the Key Lime Pie.

Chocolate Cake

Value: The prices are very reasonable.  Most items are under $10.00 and the most expensive thing on the menu is the Char Grilled Ribeye with skillet herb potatoes and house-made Worcestershire with choice of 1 side for $14.00.  My meal was a great value because the level of “original” I got was well worth it.  Elma ordered the Crab Sliders which were “delicious and full of crabmeat” and came with sweet potato fries that were done to perfection.  She ended up eating 2 sliders and taking one home (which I ate….sorry, Elma) She ate ALL the fries.

Atmosphere:  Things were not changed much from the Atlanta Bread Company layout.  There are some small tables by the fireplace which is nice……comfortable, but not memorable.

West Cobb Diner--I'm sure they will be adding to the atmosphere as they go

West Cobb Diner--I expect they will to add to the atmosphere as they go

Wait Staff:  I am going to give the wait staff a BIG pass when I am reviewing their skills.  We ate there on the third day it was open, and needless to say, there was some confusion. We waited 20 minutes for our dessert which, the waitress told us (after the fact) was being freshly prepared (we ordered peach cobbler). I went back the following week and waited over 40 minutes for a take-out order.  While I waited, I could hear the stress in the busy kitchen……chefs blaming waiters….waiters blaming chefs…and around and around.  I have to give them the benefit of the doubt and hope that things settle down and they get in their groove.  If not, the service will be the death of them….but let’s give them a chance…OK?

Senior Friendly:  The restaurant is very easy to get into–with no steps.  there are several handicapped parking places, but even if you don’t get one, the parking is convenient

Bathroom: Neat and clean with plenty of products, but let’s face it…it was only open 3 days when I went!

All in all it was a very pleasant experience.  The menu is original and diverse without being “stuffy” and stuck up.  There is a wide variety of foods that would satisfy any palate.  We will most certainly be returning to try their other menu items like the Pan Seared Top Sirloin with roasted eggplant blue-cheese butter  or  Shrimp and Mango with toasted corn, jicama, and cilantro lime dressing (Um……yum)

Please go and check it out…and let us know what you think. Were we on track? or off our rocker?

Thanks for reading
West Cobb Diner on Urbanspoon


Whitlock’s Grill

Elma and I gave Whitlock's Grill 3 stars overall

Three out of five stars now……but things are a-changin at Whitlock’s!!

Elma and I decided to eat at Whitlock’s Grill, (which was formally Chicago’s Steaks) on Whitlock Avenue about 2 miles west of the square in the Kroger shopping center.  Those of you who expect Whitlock’s to be Chicago’s are in for a disappointment. 

I would imagine it’s difficult to buy and established place, that everyone knows, and then make it your own, but that is exactly what this owner from Peru is doing….but he’s doing it gradually.

The menu now, is what I would call “familiar”.  It has the basics that one would expect on a menu: burgers, salads, and sandwiches.  But all that is expected to change in the upcoming months.

In speaking with the pleasant waitress (who is also the certified pastry chef) the owner, Fernando Vargas, wanted those who expected a Chicago’s menu to at least come in and get what they expected….for a while.

The word is, he is expected to slowly change the menu from “expected” to “pleasantly surprised”.  He plans to showcase a more unique style in both the entrees and the desserts. 

Thus this review is based on the food that is being served now, November 2009.  Elma and I plan to go back in several months to sample the new, hip and happenin menu and report to you on it.

For a synopsis of how we rate things please see our rating system.

Food quality:  Elma ordered the fish and chips.($9.99) The fish was fresh and soft, but the fries were previously frozen and gritty.  The hush puppies were crispy and good.  Says Elma:  “this is OK, but it doesn’t make my taste buds say “POW”.”

Whitlock grill's fish and chips ($9.99)

I ordered the grilled salmon ($9.99) which was a bit overcooked and not very tender, but fresh and flavorful, which made it as good as any…better ‘n some.  the only side was some steamed broccoli.  All the pieces were flowerets and no stems (thank you!) I have to admit…the plate looked a bit lonely and could have used a roll or something, no?

If you don’t eat meat, there are 3 things on the menu for you…even the salads all have meat (I guess I could pick it out, but I didn’t want to pay for it)

Whitlock Grill's grilled salmon ($9.99)

Value:  I don’t mind paying $9.99 for lunch but I expect to get a bit more than we got for it.  There were items on the lunch menu for $6.99, but it was nothing that sounded good to us.

Elma’s plate had a lot more food than mine, and she went home with a doggie bag. My plate was completely clean (I was hungry).  All is all, it was an average value.

A bright spot in the experience was the desserts.  Three of their desserts are made on site: the creme brulee, the carrot cake, and the key lime pie.  The owner and head chef  likes chocolate, so there were a lot of chocolate choices :pecan pie with chocolate chips, chocolate cheesecake, double chocolate cake, and a chocolate bundt cake.

Elma loves creme brulee, so she tried that.  It was very large, and the top sugar crust was thick (Elma picked up the pieces of sugar ice and ate them seperately..with a smile) The custard was very nice–soft and smooth…very good.

I had to try the chocolate bundt.  Even thought this was not made on site, it was very good.  Super moist little round cake with a chocolate explosion in the center covered with ice cream and whipped cream (canned I believe).  Very nice and it hit my sweet spot.

We recommend the creme brulee and the chocolate bundt!!

Atmosphere:  There has been no new changes in the set up from Chicago’s to Whitlock’s.  It was clean and neat–nice all in all.  “How would you rate the atmosphere?” I asked Elma.  “The atmosphere has to do with who you are with–not what’s on the walls.”   Smart lady.

Wait staff:  This one may be unfair, because we were the only people in the place when we went at 3:00.  The waitress that served us was very attentive (it would have been really bad if she wasn’t, right?) and very nice.  She seemed very excited about the changes that were to come in the menu…..we’ll see.

Senior Friendly:  There are 2 handicapped parking places in the front, so if it were a busy day, I don’t think we would have gotten one.  There is a ramp and  several stairs to the front door.  There are also stairs in the main part of the eating area in some places.

Bathroom:  The bathroom was very nice, fully stocked and smelling like a fresh flower.

Whitlock's Grill bathroom was fresh and clean

All in all not a bad experience.  I am very interested to see the changes that take place–it all sounds very exciting……there is talk of  “de-constructed desserts”…..very “avante gard”!

Check back with the blog after the first of the year and we will review the “new” Whitlock’s Grill!

Whitlock’s Grill’s web site is under construction at the time this blog entry was written. (Nov 2009)